“Hard to Be a God”

What could be worse than a “Ghost Fleet” scenario?


When the US Congress, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Secretary of the Navy schedule to be briefed in real time about a sci-fi book, you have to assume that the situation is real serious. And this is the case with the new techno-thriller novel “Ghost Fleet” in which World War III scenarios are presented by defense and international security experts Peter W. Singer and August Cole.

In the aspect of real-world military technology, the contents of the book is not something that is impossible to evolve in a real battle, regardless of who is attacking whom.

But exactly for this same extreme complexity of real time military technologies as featured in the “Ghost Fleet”, there exists one very essential issue: predictability of military conflicts assessed on intelligence about numbers of soldiers, horses, artillery, tanks, ships, warplanes or missiles, is not valid any more in 21st century. That makes the outcome of any future full scale global nuclear conflict practically unpredictable, and it would be unrealistic to presume that contemporary nuclear power countries are not fully aware of the unpredictability factor. All of the major advanced countries, no matter if new history or old civilization, already have too much to lose in an eventual global nuclear conflict. That would make any of them highly demotivated to initiate WW III.

Having said that, I find no ground to feel optimistic about international security prospects.

Following precisely the same techno-thriller line of “Ghost Fleet”, its nightmare can be logically expanded into an even worse scenario: a technologically advanced country or organization, not possessing any weapon of mass destruction itself, could get in position, through sophisticated interaction of high edge space and cyberspace electronic warfare and communications, to simulate a nuclear attack from one nuclear power country on another nuclear power country, thus triggering a real full scale global conflict. In the circumstances of currently achieved velocity of intercontinental ballistic missiles and the deepening international distrust – factors that take both the verification procedures and the “red button” decision making process to a critical point, it would take just seconds to get hundreds of nuclear warheads on their pre-programmed trajectories.

This type of danger, which in terms of probability is orders greater compared to one big power attacking another big power, can be crucially minimized by upgrading security cooperation among the big powers. But for this to get materialized, there is another huge obstacle to be overcome: the primitive atavistic drive to dominate the world.

Finally – technology is not everything. You have the people with their attitudes and human life values who care about the future – theirs, and the future of their children and grandchildren.

And if you really love good sci-fi, I would recommend the depths of civilizational thinking in the novels of the Strugatsky brothers (Arkady was born on this day, ninety years ago).

“Hard to Be a God”, for example.


About lubomir todorov

The years of work and studies I have spent in countries of diverse anthropological, political and cultural realities like Japan, Australia, Russia, Netherlands, New Zealand, Czechia, and my numerous visits across the globe, were abundant in meetings and conversations with not only politicians, government officials and businessmen, but also people of different existential background, ethnicity, education and profession, philosophy and religion, social status and political inclination: aboriginal painters in Australia, US generals, Japanese Buddhist and Shinto priests, Majesties and members of Royal families, Russian scientists, street Mapuche musicians in Chile, British parliamentarians, Indian philosophers, Czech university professors, CEOs of top Japanese corporations, Chinese social sciences researchers, Dutch entrepreneurs - to mention just a few. Over time all this primary data, intertwined with the everyday inflow of information about human activities all over the world and their real-time consequences, were re-assimilated in my mind through the tools of philosophy, international relations, ethics, biology, economics, history and political sciences to gradually constitute a distinct resolution to re-examine my understanding about politics and the nature of human society. Making all the time hard efforts to keep the methodology machine uncontaminated by ideological, political or personal prejudice, I clung to one rule: If you aspire for the beauty of truth, it is only facts and logic that matter. Questioning the viability of human social and political behaviour and the capacity of existing political systems to lead to where people want to be, I believe that sooner than later, in pursue of sustainable prosperity, our humanity will embrace its ultimate imperative of Civilizational Thinking. Human Civilization is the spiritual dimension of homo sapiens group survival strategy that urges humans to mutually defend their strategic self-interest by generating Civilizational Values; and the optimal political environment for that is Universal Future: a global multifaceted platform on which all polities in their ideological, political, national, cultural, ethnic, religious, racial, etc. diversity exist, interrelate and compete with each other on non-violence basis.
This entry was posted in Brutal Logic, Reports from Human Jungle and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s